Skip to main content

Who's Who

The three men woke up in a white room each handcuffed to a table. As they cleared the grogginess from their eyes they noticed the gun lying on that table.

“Good morning!” a speaker blared. “It’s very simple. There you sit. A medic, a cook, and a hitman. To live, decipher who the hitman is. The chains will release when he is dead, or he kills you. Let’s see what happens!”

The recording abruptly stopped followed by silence. There was a loud scramble as all three reached for the gun. One snapping it up and pointing it at the other two. The three men freeze, and silence falls over them again.

"Well we know he's not the killer." smirked one of the unarmed men.

“How can you be so sure?” said the other.

"If he were, we'd be dead now," he replied.

“I'm the cook.” said the man with the gun. “Now who are you two?”

One yells out pointing to the other, “He’s the killer! I'm the medic. Quick! Shoot him!”

“Wait cook!” the other says. “He's lying! I'm the medic! Shoot him and let’s get out of here!”

“Shut up!” the cook screams, silencing the argument.

The three are quiet again for a moment then in a flash the cook fires the pistol. One man slides as far as his chains will allow and slumps over blood dripping from his head. The chains make an electric clink and fall to the ground.

“How did you know?” the medic said gasping in awe. “How did you know he was the killer?”

“I didn't.”

“What do you mean?” the medic asked.

“He reached for the gun first. Had fast reflexes. He must be trained. But he wasn't the killer.” the cook replied.

“What? I’m lost. What the hell are you talking about?” the medic asked confused.

“The recording said to kill the hitman. A hitman does it for money. Killers are different. Killers kill for… well… fun.” the cook laughed raising the gun.

“Wait! What are you doing?” the medic begged “You said you were the cook!”

“I am the cook,” he said with a grin. “And don’t worry. I won’t let any piece of you two go to waste.”

🛈 - Posted on r/shortscarystories. Thx for reading!
  ◘  Follow Me on Reddit  ◘

Comments

Most Viewed

Teeth

Matthew’s mouth was bloody and disgusting. He was cursed. On the very first day of his life, the doctor gave him to his mother after a hard delivery, and to her surprise, she found he already had a teeny tiny tooth. Her surprise was soon followed by disgust at how very ugly the tooth was. As well as all the others to follow. She made Matthew brush five, sometimes six, times a day. She made him floss and gargle with mouthwash. She routinely plagued the neighborhood dentist with checkups and cleanings. But there was no use. Matthew’s teeth were always crooked and discolored. Always bleeding and infected.  After many years of teasing by others in school, and even more years of study, Matthew graduated from college. He was very talented and quickly rose to the top of his field. Despite his appearance, he found he was very well respected and soon also found himself a very rich man. Still, the shame of his unsightly appearance followed him and he spent most of his days feeling very lonely.

Over the Bar

 "My dad told me that if you swing over the bar you'll turn inside out like a sock." "No way! That’s ridiculous." "Yes way! It’s physics. You just have never heard of it happening because it's impossible." "It's not impossible." "It's physically impossible man. No one can do it." "I can do it." “You can’t swing over the bar Cody” “Yes I can. I’ve done it before. Lots of times.” "OK. Prove it.” “I don’t feel like it right now Joel.” “See. You’re just saying that cause you can’t do it.” “I can do it. Just not right now. I've got a stomach ache.” “I dare you to swing over the bar Cody. I double dare you." Cody couldn’t turn down a double dare. He would be ridiculed for chickening out until the end of the school year. He had no choice but to give it his best shot. Hesitantly he walked to the swing set and sat down in the seat. Silently Joel watched the swing climb into the air. Cody's legs shot up

A Babysitting Job

“I can see your child through the window,” the voice on the phone said. “He’ll be dead before you’re home.” The phone cut out and Ben immediately dialed 911. “It’s probably just a prank but we’ll send someone by.” the dispatcher said. “Thank you, officer.” Ben hung up and several minutes later the phone rang again. “Mr. Sunders… I just wanted to let you know that we checked it out. Everything is fine. We spoke with the babysitter and all is well.” “Thank you so much. I hate that I wasted your time, officer.” “No problem at all. It was on my way home and the sitter seemed like a nice fella.” “Did you speak with Jordan?” “Yes sir. We talked to him. Good guy.” “Officer Can you please go back to my house right now. I’m on my way there.” “Mr. Sunders like I said we checked every...” “Jordan is a female, officer. Whoever you spoke to wasn’t her.” Ben rushed towards his house dialing Jordan’s cell repeatedly, each time getting voicemail. He slammed on the brakes in front of his house just mis